Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Elysian Beach Resort and Windward Passage Hotel? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next St. Thomas getaway.
Best for couples, families, and all-ages travelers who want a beachfront St. Thomas resort setting with direct Cowpet Bay Beach access, on-site dining, a pool, and a quieter East End feel.
Better for travelers who want a practical downtown Charlotte Amalie harbor hotel with easier access to town, shopping, ferry connections, and a more urban St. Thomas base.
If you want a beach-focused stay with resort amenities, direct access to Cowpet Bay, two on-site restaurants, a pool, hot tub, tennis, and water activities nearby, Elysian Beach Resort is the stronger fit.
If your priority is convenience over a resort-style beach setting—especially being closer to Charlotte Amalie, the harbor area, and downtown logistics—Windward Passage Hotel is usually the more practical choice.
Bottom line: choose Elysian Beach Resort for a relaxed East End beach resort stay; choose Windward Passage Hotel for a more central, city-and-harbor-oriented St. Thomas hotel base.
| Category | Elysian Beach Resort | Windward Passage Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | All-ages beachfront resort on Cowpet Bay with a relaxed East End setting, resort amenities, and a stronger vacation-by-the-water feel. | Downtown harbor-area hotel that works best as a convenient St. Thomas base for travelers who value access to town over a secluded resort atmosphere. |
| Location | On the East End of St. Thomas at 6800 Estate Nazareth, next to the St. Thomas Yacht Club, with direct access to Cowpet Bay Beach. | In Charlotte Amalie’s harbor/downtown area, better positioned for travelers who want town access rather than an East End beach-resort location. |
| Rooms & Suites | Suite-style resort accommodations suited to longer, relaxed stays; some units include added residential-style conveniences, and suite assignment may happen at check-in. | More traditional hotel-style accommodations, best for travelers who plan to spend more time out in town, on ferries, or exploring than staying put at the property. |
| Dining | Two on-site restaurants, including casual beachside dining at Sangria’s Beachside Bistro and seafood-focused Caribbean Fish Market, plus a bar/pool bar. | Better for travelers who expect to use nearby downtown dining options as part of the stay rather than relying on a beach-resort restaurant setup. |
| Pools & Beach | Direct Cowpet Bay Beach access, an outdoor pool, hot tub, and poolside bar make it the stronger choice for beach-and-pool days. | More of a harbor/city hotel setting than a beach resort, so it is better for location convenience than for an on-property beach experience. |
| Kids & Family | All-ages resort where children are welcome and family rooms are listed, with beach, pool, and casual dining that can work well for families. | Can work for families who want a central base, but it is less of a resort-style family beach stay than Elysian Beach Resort. |
| Price & Value | Best value when you’ll actually use the beach access, pool, hot tub, tennis, water activities, and on-site dining as part of the vacation. | Best value when your trip is built around downtown convenience, harbor access, short stays, or using the hotel mostly as a practical base. |
Rooms and suites at Elysian Beach Resort are better suited to travelers who want a resort-style stay on the East End, with beach access and on-property amenities shaping the experience.
Elysian is the better pick if you want your room to be part of a beach-resort stay rather than just a place to sleep between outings.
Windward Passage Hotel is the more straightforward hotel option, geared toward travelers who want to be closer to Charlotte Amalie and the harbor instead of tucked into an East End resort.
If you want a practical downtown base and do not need a beach-resort atmosphere, Windward Passage Hotel makes more sense.
Dining at Elysian Beach Resort is a clear advantage if you want convenient on-property options, with both casual beachfront fare and a more seafood-forward dinner setting available.
Expect:
Windward Passage Hotel is better viewed as a downtown hotel base where nearby Charlotte Amalie dining can be part of the plan, rather than a self-contained beach dining experience.
If on-site beach dining matters, Elysian Beach Resort has the edge; if you prefer downtown flexibility, Windward Passage Hotel is the simpler fit.
Elysian Beach Resort’s biggest advantage is its direct Cowpet Bay Beach setting, paired with an outdoor pool, hot tub, and poolside bar for easy resort days.
Windward Passage Hotel is better for travelers who want to be near the downtown harbor area, not for those seeking an on-property beach resort experience.
If your St. Thomas trip is about easy beach-and-pool time, Elysian Beach Resort is the clear winner.
Elysian Beach Resort is an all-ages property where children are welcome, and its beach, pool, casual restaurant options, and suite-style setup can make family trips feel easier.
Windward Passage Hotel can work for families who want a central Charlotte Amalie base, but it is less about resort-style family downtime and more about location convenience.
If your family wants a beach-resort setting with more on-site vacation time, Elysian Beach Resort is the better match.
Elysian Beach Resort offers the most value when you plan to use the resort itself: Cowpet Bay Beach, the pool, hot tub, tennis court, water activities, and on-site dining are the reasons to book it.
Windward Passage Hotel is the better value if location is the point of the stay—especially for travelers who want a downtown Charlotte Amalie harbor base and do not need a full beach-resort setup.
Choose Elysian if you want direct Cowpet Bay Beach access, a relaxed East End resort setting, on-site restaurants, a pool, hot tub, and an all-ages vacation atmosphere.
Windward Passage Hotel is the better pick if you want a central Charlotte Amalie harbor-area base and plan to prioritize convenience, town access, and getting around.
For travelers who want beach time to be the centerpiece of the trip, Elysian Beach Resort delivers the stronger St. Thomas resort experience.
If you want a more practical city hotel feel and do not need an on-property beach, Windward Passage Hotel is the more efficient choice.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Elysian Beach Resort:
